Remember when Obama shut down the government for 16 days to force Obamacare, the most expensive healthcare legislation ever passed? Murph gripes about Trump getting into his pocketbook, I was self employed and my insurance company dropped health coverage after it passed, so I had to sign up with another company for 4x the amount. That was fun as I was just really trying to get established. I was told I shouldn’t gripe though because it was for the greater good.
Nice try with the Obama story. The government shutdown in 2013 was triggered by a conflict where House Republicans attempted to defund or delay the ACA. This opposition, not Obama, threatened to halt parts of the government's operations related to the ACA.
It doesn’t mean squat today. Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, a large number of Americans are expected to lose their subsidies for ACA insurance. Without enhanced subsidies, out-of-pocket premium payments for ACA enrollees may rise by an average of over 75% in 2026, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.
The Trump administration’s solution is to allow a hardship exemption for people who lose ACA coverage to buy low-premium, high-deductible "catastrophic plans.” However, in 2026, these plans will have deductibles over $10,000. With Marketplace subsidies ending, premiums may be as high or higher than for better coverage. These plans are unsuitable for those with chronic conditions (e.g., asthma or diabetes) or ongoing care needs like chemotherapy.
Another "solution" from the Trump administration is allowing consumers to purchase "short-term health insurance plans." Unlike ACA-compliant plans, short-term plans are not mandated to cover essential health benefits, including maternity care, mental health services, and prescription drugs. In addition, these plans may vary in coverage based on pre-existing conditions and can include annual or lifetime coverage limits.
Nobody likes "stunts" and "show votes" for media attention, which does little in the way of advancing policy. In this case, however, I see the government shutdown as a fight worth having.