And it's possible the dude from Furman (or wherever) is great! Those guys turn out great sometimes. I liked the Groce hire okay despite him not being good enough here, but we were in a very different scenario that last Weber year than we are right now.
It's just a huge, huge risk, with significantly more likely downsides than upsides.
To get deep in the tournament consistently, step #1 is to make the tournament consistently. We haven't had a coach do that pre-Underwood since Self (whose tournament success here would also probably be getting hammered on Twitter right now - "why are we trending down!?"). The idea that we can just throw Underwood on the scrap pile and we'll get a guy who can for sure do that is possible, but FAR from likely. We're much more likely to get a guy who can't even get that step #1 done.