Let’s look at all the busts Underwood has recruited that has lots of hype, but if you actually looked at tape could tell they would suck.
Omar Payne- listen to Werner hype this guy up all off-season. Completely sucked
Austin Hutcherson- seriously. A D3 guy got insane amount of hype and did nothing.
Curbelo- lot of hype. Completely sucked.
Mark Smith- Underwood claimed he was like Jason Kidd. Ugh no.
Tevian Jones- lots of hype, sucked
Mark Alstork- sucked
I think he said Mark Smith had Kidd potential. Lots of people overrated Smith. He dominated metro east competition and never got exposed in national aau. In the end, he was a good college role player with a helicopter parent.
Curbelo was a stud before the brain injury. Saying he completely sucked is proof you are an asshole. A minor league asshole at that.
I'd have liked to have seen Payne redshirt and work with Geoff and TA. Good athlete with size and strength. No skills. Wasn't he rated about the same as Kofi out of high school?
I don't recall expectations being overly high for Alstork. He was worth a shot because nobody else wanted to come here.
Tevian Jones looked like a steal. Was not a plan A recruit, but a good athlete with size and skills, top 125ish prospect. Had off court issues.
Austin Hutcherson is an exceptional athlete with some basketball skills. We never saw him play due to injuries. Possible other issues?
Another thing is Underwood often says nice things about his players in public. It might be a safe bet that he saves the criticism for private moments.