I get it. But do you really think Madigan and Cullerton would negotiate in good faith? I don't. Big Jim, etc. would have had a tough time dealing with that crew. George Ryan obviously fit right in.
When Rauner started to slash funding for social services, high-ed, local governments, schools, infrastructure, etc., the fight was on. He managed to unite the various caucuses within the Democratic party. Madigan and Cullerton barely had to lift a finger to organize the opposition. Their existence didn’t even matter. What happened to the labor movement in Wisconsin and Indiana wasn’t going to work in a state like Illinois, with its long and proud history of collective bargaining and labor organizing.
Rauner should have played the long game. First stop the hemorrhaging and splintering within the GOP party organization. Recruit better candidates to run for office. Work to elect more Republicans to the House and take control of the Senate. That would have given him leverage to seek labor reforms down the road, probably in his second term. Instead, he decided to blow up the state budgetary process in his first two years of office.
Here’s another thing. As you know, not all labor unions are in bed with the Democrats. The construction trades, teamsters, electrical workers, plumbers and public safety unions tend to be more conservative and will support moderate Republicans. Rauner’s sledgehammer approach left these unions with no place to go but to form an alliance with the AFL-CIO, AFSCME, UAW and Illinois Federation of Teachers.
And we all know the rest of the story.