Perception made the difference. Most people would probably say Wisconsin overachieved quite a bit, and Illinois under achieved a bit. Kofi also had a couple of duds down the stretch.
Which duds?
Compare them to the duds Davis had in the league. Davis went three games down the stretch where he shot 35% from the floor. Kofi shot less than 35% from the floor in two total games.
Agree it was 'perception', or narrative, but that's incredibly dumb. And basically the opposite rationale that explained last year's voting.
Johnny Davis had games of 15% shooting (four points!!), 22% shooting, 26% shooting, 31% shooting, 33% shooting, 36% shooting in Big Ten games.
Kofi's five worst Big Ten games were two games shooting 33%, one at 44%, one at 46%, and one at 50%. All in double figures.
And underachieved? We have had among the most injuries of any team nationally and won the league.