The article appears to be dated within about a week after Gain of Function and PPP3 wording was changed in the NIH website.
The 2016 Ecohealth grant required progress reports, which Ecohealth was not fully compliant with and required reminders of that lack of compliance to Ecohealth.
The grant request appears to have involved mentions of work at UNC, which NIH/NIAID reminded Ecohealth that any work outside of China required additional information.
Ecohealth's response ? Thank you for bringing that to our attention, it was a "clerical error".
Interesting that the author links to work being done by Ralph Baric at UNC.
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2015.18787
The data ? I believe it's still under China review before it can be posted, as per the grant wording.
Re Gain of function terminology ?
Daszak emailed NIH/NIAID in July 2016 thanking them for lifting the funding on, in his own words, "Gain of Function research".
What does "Gain of Function research" mean? I don't know. It appears to mean different things in different contexts. In general, it seems to mean genetically altering organisms in ways that give them new abilities. Would researching GMO foods apply?
Here we are talking in the context of microbiology, specifically pathogenic virology. But giving a virus new abilities is not a concern unless it makes it more infectious. Even then, it may or may not be deemed dangerous.
That seems to be the rationale behind distinguishing GoF in general from GoF of concern. When talking about a pause, that strikes me as reasonable. YMMV.
It is not shocking that scientists differ when we get into gray areas. Some examples are clearly not of concern, others are, a few are debatable.
Ecohealth had a couple minor technical clerical errors? I am shocked! Suddenly the right cares about bureaucratic red tape and hoop jumping?
The author of the article "Amber Dance is an award-winning freelance science journalist based in Southern California. She earned a Ph.D. in biology from the University of California, San Diego, before retraining as a journalist at the University of California, Santa Cruz." -- bio
The author of the letter you posted is a Republican Senator. "He attended Tarkio College in Missouri for one year on a football scholarship before enrolling at Santa Fe Community College (now Santa Fe College) in Gainesville, Florida. He earned his Bachelor of Arts degree in political science from the University of Florida in 1993 and his Juris Doctor cum laude from the University of Miami School of Law" -- wiki