Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

November 19, 2026, 08:21:50 PM

Login with username, password and session length

Recent

Members
Stats
  • Total Posts: 187854
  • Total Topics: 1562
  • Online Today: 538
  • Online Ever: 8243
  • (July 10, 2026, 02:18:36 PM)
Users Online
Users: 3
Guests: 476
Total: 479

WTF is wrong with Minnesota?

  • 1537 Replies
  • 65546 Views

0 Members and 12 Guests are viewing this topic.

*

ThePAMan

  • *****
  • 33892
  • +626/-2518
  • Because "PussyMan" and "PenisMan" were trademarked
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1530 on: Today at 04:54:09 PM »
It has not been 40 years. 

This fuckling asshole should be strung up for destroying millions of kids' lives. Of course the SDA/Progressives are defending incompetence and a fucking fraud. Just should have put the money in the pockets of Muslim fraudsters in Minnesota!

https://williamsrecord.com/464436/features/lucy-calkins-73-taught-america-to-read-the-reading-wars-have-called-her-work-into-question/

Quote
If you’re a Williams College student reading this article, Lucy Calkins ’73 probably taught you how to do so. Maybe you memorized sight words. Maybe you learned to read through “just right” books for your reading level. Maybe your teacher had you guess how to pronounce an unknown word with context clues. Maybe you were encouraged to look at the surrounding pictures.

These are the hallmarks of Calkins’s Units of Study curriculum, which she designed at the Columbia University Teachers College. Her program was first mandated in New York City schools by Mayor Michael Bloomberg in 2003 and has since spread to school districts across the U.S. According to Calkins, Units of Study is a “balanced literacy” curriculum, which emphasizes learning words through their context and meaning rather than by letter sound. Units of Study, Calkins said, combines reader engagement with explicit instruction on the skills and strategies required for effective reading.

Calkins is largely influential in literacy education, and she is also largely controversial. The dominance of balanced literacy is often blamed for American students’ poor standardized test scores in reading and writing. New scientific research, her critics say, indicates that using phonics — sounding words out letter by letter — is the best way to teach reading and is more effective than Calkins’s theory of “whole word learning.” States have started dropping Units of Study, though Berkshire County public schools still use the curriculum.

Quote
Just as Calkins’s work took the education world by storm, so too did a podcast by journalist Emily Hanford, Sold a Story, in fall 2022. Criticism of Calkins’s approach had already been rising for years, but it was Hanford who delivered a scathing indictment of Units of Study.

“Kids are not being taught how to read because for decades, teachers have been sold an idea about reading and how children learn to do it, and that idea is wrong,” Hanford said in the first episode. “The people who have been selling this idea — I don’t have any reason to believe they thought it was wrong … but they believed so deeply in their idea about how to do that that they somehow ignored or explained away a whole lot of evidence that showed the idea was wrong.”

“These people” largely refers to Calkins, now the target of parents’ and teachers’ ire across the nation. They have two main frustrations.

The first is that “literacy by vibes,” as The New Yorker dubbed Units of Study, isn’t based in science but is retrograde and should be phased out in favor of phonics. “[Calkins] says there are important things about how children learn to read that she didn’t know,” Hanford said in her podcast. “She told The New York Times earlier this year that my reporting helped change her mind, but the research showing those strategies were a bad idea has been around for decades. Why didn’t she know about it?”

Hanford pointed to decades of research — beginning in the early 2000s, before Units of Study was even implemented — that suggest phonics are far more effective at educating early readers.

Others fault Units of Study as a curriculum for the privileged, as students from affluent backgrounds grow up reading with support systems in place. These students, Calkins’s critics argue, grew up as Units of Study poster children: wealthy, enrolled in a well-rated school, and raised by well-educated parents who modeled and encouraged reading for pleasure. Children who take naturally to reading do just fine under Units of Study, they say, but those who do not — students with learning disabilities, for example — will struggle.

Berkshire County residents were upset with Calkins’s system as well. “Ever since the alphabet’s invention, phonics has been the method by which people universally learned to read,” Ruth Heuberger, a volunteer reading tutor in Great Barrington, wrote in a letter to The Berkshire Eagle. “However, for the past few generations of American schoolchildren, it was largely put aside in favor of Whole Word Recognition [the word-recognition philosophy of Units of Study]. Motivated children are hardly a positive example of this method as they often learn to read in spite of their educators. Today, tragically, perfectly average children cannot sound out the simplest words.”

Insofar as the reading wars can be won, phonics appear to be winning. In 2022, Calkins released an updated version of Units of Study that included daily phonics lessons for the first time. Many school districts or states have dropped Units of Study altogether or passed laws requiring similar phonics instruction.
Mark Carman: "The Whitlock!...Caleb Williams failed Wayne Whitlock." Been told I need to take my dick out my mouth so maybe I "wont [sic] sound like such a fucking faggot all the time[.]"

Tempo: "PAMan is a pot stirrer and agent provocateur"

*

alum74

  • *****
  • 2936
  • +1509/-124
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1531 on: Today at 06:08:28 PM »
Alum = Tempo is a match?

Does the Flailing NYTimes suit you better?  https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/08/us/lucy-calkins-teachers-college.html
 
https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2020/01/27/lucy-calkins-reading-materials-review

https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2023/09/08/controversial-reading-project-teachers-college-will-dissolve

So, the Ivy League Morons at Columbia University dissolved the Teachers College Reading and Writing Project in fall 2023, because it was determined by a groundbreaking study in 2020 that its instructional program was not serving the reading needs of students.  So be it. 

Universities have shut down programs over questionable results before and will do so again. That is sometimes how the system works, though better and broader performance measures would clearly help.



*

murphstahoe

  • *****
  • 9166
  • +2143/-143
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1532 on: Today at 07:10:46 PM »
Minnesota drops to 49th. Hang a banner.
Yes, they assign numbers after the top 25.

"The "2027 Business Benchmarks Report: Minnesota's Economic Runway" ranked Minnesota 49th among the 50 states in GDP per capita growth this decade, looking at data from 2019-25."
https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/articles/minnesota-economy-falls-behind-nearly-211400806.html

Minnesota was ranked 12th, squarely in the top 25 (👏👏👏), when Walz took office.
Thank you Gov Walz !!!
Vote Blue !!!

Maybe this is just because Minnesota is full of dumb shits who can't do anything useful?

*

murphstahoe

  • *****
  • 9166
  • +2143/-143
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1533 on: Today at 07:12:21 PM »
North Dakota came in 4th. Nuff said.

Drilling for a lot of Nat Gas will get you up there but won't keep you up there. Ask Pennsylvania

*

murphstahoe

  • *****
  • 9166
  • +2143/-143
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1534 on: Today at 07:13:32 PM »
"student academic proficiency (measured on state tests and ACT scores) has declined for years. ACT scores and real academic knowledge for the class of 2025 was at an all-time low, even as graduation rates soared to record-setting highs. (One questions if the high graduation rate, which boosted Minnesota’s national ranking in the Kids Count Report, accurately reflected student achievement.) Last year (2025), less than half of all students tested as grade-level proficient on either math or reading state tests. Those academic declines on state assessments began a decade ago."

"the state ranks higher academically than “backwater” states like Mississippi."

"one thing is statistically true: at this point, a young, poor black boy in Mississippi will score higher on his tests than a similar student in Minnesota."
https://www.americanexperiment.org/minnesotas-national-education-ranking-falls-to-21st/

You'll graduate but you won't math and read like a Mississippi kid can.

Oh boy. Hang a banner.

Lead mines are very profitable until your kids can't read.

*

murphstahoe

  • *****
  • 9166
  • +2143/-143
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1535 on: Today at 07:17:42 PM »
Phonics shmonics

The kids can't read because you shit heads give them iPads instead of books.

*

ThePAMan

  • *****
  • 33892
  • +626/-2518
  • Because "PussyMan" and "PenisMan" were trademarked
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1536 on: Today at 07:24:53 PM »
Phonics shmonics

The kids can't read because you shit heads give them iPads instead of books.

Uh, nice try.
« Last Edit: Today at 07:27:03 PM by ThePAMan »
Mark Carman: "The Whitlock!...Caleb Williams failed Wayne Whitlock." Been told I need to take my dick out my mouth so maybe I "wont [sic] sound like such a fucking faggot all the time[.]"

Tempo: "PAMan is a pot stirrer and agent provocateur"

*

No one in Mn

  • *****
  • 13471
  • +180/-2751
    • View Profile
Re: WTF is wrong with Minnesota?
« Reply #1537 on: Today at 08:14:01 PM »
Nonetheless, "one thing is statistically true: at this point, a young, poor black boy in Mississippi will score higher on his tests than a similar student in Minnesota."

Minnesota spends 1/3rd more per student than Mississippi.
Still hiding behind innuendo and practicing the art of omission.