I have “allowed” criticism of “my guy.” To the point where I said your position was justifiable. If thats not an allowance” of criticism, I don’t know what to fucking tell you. What irked me was the complete lack of distribution of blame and the excessive Fields hate. I can only say so many times I get the case for moving on from Fields.
The hate you're talking about is pure projection. I can't speak for JJ or the guy who exclusively trolls you, but I certainly never hated Fields. Hell, I was stoked as fuck when we moved up to get him and wanted him to be the answer badly. I was stoked when we got DJ Moore for him and expected him to have a breakout year, which would've been the absolute ideal situation - having QB figured out but also having two top-10 picks in the draft (including #1) with your QB situation already sorted is a perfect situation. And I wasn't alone; Justin Fields got more bets and money on him for MVP last year than any other player. But with DJ Moore as his WR1 instead of Mooney, he was .. about the same. I was a HELL of a lot more fair to Fields than you've been to Caleb Williams so far, and it isn't remotely close or debatable.
It's not hate. We pointed out when he played badly and you simply would not allow that. You insisted that when Fields played badly, it was everyone else's fault - every single time, all of last year. I literally cannot remember a single time I pointed out something Fields had done poorly and you just said, "yep, gotta be better" - but I DO remember a time I pointed out something he did well and you got mad that I later acknowledged that he did something poorly on a later play without also acknowledging the good play again.